FREE ELECTRONIC LIBRARY - Books, abstracts, thesis

Pages:     | 1 |   ...   | 3 | 4 || 6 | 7 |   ...   | 11 |

«A. Dirk Moses Whoever thou art... by ceasing to take part... in the public worship of God, as it now is (with the claim that it is the ...»

-- [ Page 5 ] --

Well, it does exist; but because we have murdered or broken its bodily carriers, and because, in a climate of an unbinding reconciliation, we are in the process of letting everything be forgiven and forgotten too.... we are now forced into the historical irony of taking up the Jewish question without the Jews.”72 Habermas made it his mission to embody this spirit, to pose the Jewish question in a Germany virtually bereft of Jews and to defend it against its enemies. In the 1950s and 1960s these enemies were the former conservative revolutionaries like Carl Schmitt, Arnold Gehlen, and Helmut Schelsky, and their postwar successors, the liberal positivists of the technocratic intelligentsia like Hermann Lübbe and Hans Albert.

After the 1980s and, above all, during the Historikerstreit and unification debates in the early 1990s, Habermas attacked conservative memory politics that he saw running counter to his postnational philosophy of history and the lessons of Auschwitz. His non-German German philosophy of history took the following form. The central event of modernity was the French Revolution because it actualized a new principle of sovereignty, the nation rather than the dynastic monarch. This historical progress brought its own problems because the “nation”—hitherto the appellation for a prepolitical ethnic community—became the defining term of citizenship within the state.

So while the “nation-state” provided the legal forum for its democratization,

71. Ibid., 41–42. 72. Ibid., 42.64 Dilemmas of Identity after the Holocaust

this process occurred at the expense of ethnic minorities because a “sovereign people” presupposed a common will and therefore a homogeneous population. From its inception, then, the nation-state contained the contradictory principles of the prepolitical attachment to particular ethnic and cultural life forms (which restricts full membership to its own) and the universalistic implications of a democratic constitutionalism (which conceives of the nation as a community of citizens, i.e., citizenship is conferred on those who consent to certain procedures and processes of government irrespective of their ethnic or cultural background).73 The historical process in Western Europe since the French Revolution has been constituted by the untangling of these contradictory ideas of the nation. The German problem was that this process had been obstructed: ever since the so-called Wars of Liberation against French occupation, the nationalist principle has dominated the democratic one. National Socialism was the ultimate apotheosis of the nation conceived in prepolitical, racial terms. Germany was able to develop into a civic community only after it had experienced a radical caesura with its past in 1945, by abandoning the Romantic tradition with its anti-Semitism, obscurantism, and Deutschtümlerei (hyper-Germanness) for the universalism of the Western Enlightenment.74 Indeed, the conclusion that Habermas drew from Auschwitz was that “the Germans have forfeited the right to base their political identity on grounds other than the universal principles of citizenship in whose light national traditions are no longer unscrutinized but are appropriated only critically and self-critically.”75 Since the Holocaust, Germans could have not a national identity but a constitutional patriotism, because they could not “rely on the continuities of history.”76 The constituJürgen Habermas, “Citizenship and National Identity: Some Reflections on the Future of Europe,” Praxis International 12 (1992): 2–3.

74. Jürgen Habermas, Die nachholende Revolution (Frankfurt am Main: Suhrkamp, 1990), 99, 162.

75. Ibid., 220; Jürgen Habermas, “Historical Consciousness and Post-traditional Identity,” in The New Conservatism: Cultural Criticism and the Historian’s Debate, by Jürgen Habermas, trans.

Shierry Weber Nicholsen (Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 1994), 259: “Every identity that establishes membership in a collectivity and that defines the set of situations in which those belonging to the collectivity can say ‘we’ in the emphatic sense seems to be part of an unquestioned background that necessarily remains untouched by reflection.”

76. Jürgen Habermas, “Der DM Nationalismus,” Die Zeit, March 30, 1990; Habermas, “Die zweite Lebenslüge der Bundesrepublik: Wir sind wieder ‘normal’ geworden,” Die Zeit, December 11, 1992; Habermas, “Historical Consciousness and Post-traditional Identity,” 255. For commentary on Habermas and unification see Howard Williams, Catherine Bishop, and Colin Wright, “German (Re)unification: Habermas and His Critics,” German Politics 5 (1996): 214–39.

A. Dirk Moses 65 tional patriot’s reading of the past was necessarily critical, with he or she appropriating only what accords with the universal principles of democratic constitutionalism.77 Only a constitutional patriotism, with its renunciation of the German Sonderweg, could ensure the country’s continued attachment to the Western community of values. And such a patriotism could be secured only if consciousness of Auschwitz were placed at the center of collective identity, because it was the thorn in the flesh that provokes critical reflection and dissolution of the national “we.”78 To be effectively normal, it was imperative to consolidate the critical culture that broke through with the Historikerstreit, the controversy that embedded the proposition in public culture that the Holocaust was unique. The historian Jürgen Kocka expressed this position in 1988 with his elegantly framed formulation that “this break [from German tradition] stands at the center of our [Federal Republican] tradition.”79 The problem with (re)unification in 1990, Habermas feared, was that it threatened to undermine this nascent anamnestic culture that non-German Germans had developed in the Federal Republic. He was referring to the antinationalism that had been developing slowly in West Germany since the 1950s, which had culminated in the country as “civilian power” and “human rights society” committed to demilitarization and multilateralism.80 His views were not isolated; they characterized the leftist intelligentsia generally. Grass famously pronounced that Auschwitz had disqualified Germany from having a united nation-state, while the Social Democratic chancellor candidate Oskar Lafontaine said that such an ideal had been historically superseded.81 Prominent journalists in major newspapers like Die Zeit also

77. Jürgen Habermas, “On the Public Use of History: The Official Self-Understanding of the Federal Republic Is Breaking Up,” in Forever in the Shadow of Hitler? Original Documents of the Historikerstreit, the Controversy concerning the Singularity of the Holocaust, trans. James Knowlton and Truett Cates (Atlantic Highlands, NJ: Humanities, 1993), 166.

78. Jürgen Habermas, “A Kind of Settlement of Damages: The Apologetic Tendencies in German History Writing,” in Forever in the Shadow of Hitler? 43; Habermas, “Historical Consciousness and Post-traditional Identity,” 264.

79. Jürgen Kocka, “Deutsche Identität und historischer Vergleich: Nach dem ‘Historikerstreit,’” Aus Politik und Zeitgeschichte, September 30, 1988, 28.

80. Habermas, Die nachholende Revolution, 159, 215; Hanns W. Maull, “Germany and Japan:

The New Civilian Powers,” Foreign Affairs 69, no. 5 (1990): 91–107; Hans Karl Rupp, Politik nach Auschwitz: Ausgangspunkte, Konflikte, Konsens (Münster: Lit, 2005), 5. See also Timothy Garton Ash, In Europe’s Name: Germany and the Divided Continent (London: Vintage, 1994).

81. Jochen Fischer and Hans Karl Rupp, “Deutsche Vereinigung und NS-Vergangenheit,” Aus Politik und Zeitgeschichte, October 19, 2005, 41.

66 Dilemmas of Identity after the Holocaust applied this philosophy of history to the new geopolitics of the initial post– Cold War years. Europe must move beyond the divisive paradigm of the nationstate, the journalist Theo Sommer insisted. Germany, in particular, could not rehabilitate its nation-state “but must overcome it in Europe.”82 German nationalism, however tempered, was ultimately incompatible with European peace.

The nation’s size and economic power would eventually manifest itself in military terms, he warned. Should a “normal” relationship to the past develop, it would be only a matter of time before the old German policies reemerged.83 Germany could lead the way in renouncing sovereignty. “Our goal must be, first, to overcome the nation-state—in all of Europe. The hope of the future does not lie in nation-states; not in the compromise-less representations of particular self-assertions, nor in the vain jockeying for national profiles. It lies in combination and cooperation, in the progressive abandonment of national sovereignty to supranational institutions in common issues.”84 Rather than see the Berlin Republic as a continuation of the Bismarckian project, Habermas invited Germans to believe that the former Federal Republic’s history had more in common with Italy, France, and the United States than the former German Democratic Republic (GDR). What mattered was the universalist political principles of democratic constitutionalism, not the prepolitical bonds of ethnicity or culture. “Their [East Germany’s] history is not our History.”85 He viewed German unification in 1990 as an exercise in extending liberal democracy and civil rights to unfree lands rather than in terms of “the prepolitical unity of a community with a shared common historical destiny.”86 In other words, the political consciousness Habermas entreated was entirely ahistorical. Once the reflexive move was made, political consciousness became purely procedural, allowing a tolerant pluralism of other, non-German life forms. “[This identity] exists only in the method of the public, discursive battle around the interpretation of a constitutional patriotism, which must be

82. Theo Sommer, “Unser nunmehr fertiges Vaterland,” Die Zeit, June 29, 1990; Ulrich Greiner, “Das Phantom der Nation: Warum wir keine Nation sind und warum wir keine werden müssen,” Die Zeit, March 16, 1990.

83. Theo Sommer, “Keine Sehnsucht nach Stahlgewittern,” Die Zeit, August 31, 1990; Peter Glotz, “Wider den Feuilleton-Nationalismus,” Die Zeit, April 19, 1991. Although Eberhard Jäckel cannot be placed in the leftist camp, his reading of European history leads him to much the same conclusions. See his essay “Deutschland zwischen Geschichte und Zukunft,” in Deutschland in der internationalen Politik, ed. Hartmut Wasser and Norbert Kruse (Weingarten: Pädagogische Hochschule, 1992), 87–103.

84. Sommer, “Keine Sehnsucht nach Stahlgewittern.”

85. Jürgen Habermas, “Die andere Zerstörung der Vernunft,” Die Zeit, May 10, 1990.

86. Habermas, “Citizenship and National Identity,” 2–3.

A. Dirk Moses 67 concretized in particular historical circumstances.”87 For that reason, he greeted with alarm the debate in the early 1990s about restricting political asylum while welcoming ethnic Germans from Eastern Europe. Germany was becoming more instead of less German: the “repressed feeling that Germany is becoming more German has a paralyzing effect.”88 Habermas was well aware that Germans could not cut themselves off from the national past even though the Federal Republic marked a radically new and positive departure in German history. Although not directly culpable for the Nazi misdeeds, Germans could not wash their hands of the past with the fatuous excuse, used by Helmut Kohl, of their “late birth.” They were collectively liable for what happened by historical and cultural—familial—

prepolitical bonds:

Our own life is linked to the life context in which Auschwitz was possible not by contingent circumstances but intrinsically. Our form of life is connected with that of our parents and grandparents through a web of familial, local, political, and intellectual traditions that is difficult to disentangle— that is, through a historical milieu that made us what and who we are today.

None of us can escape this milieu, because our identities, both as individuals and as Germans, are indissolubly interwoven with it.89 There is a glaring contradiction in his approach, symptomatic of the impossibility for the non-German German subjectivity to be conceived in isolation from the society it seeks to transform. On the one hand, Habermas asked Germans to remember their continuing responsibility for Auschwitz, which meant demanding that they understood themselves historically as a prepolitical national community. But on the other, he insisted that Germans understand themselves politically as an ahistorical, democratically self-willed, political collective. Alternatively: Germans were held responsible (guilty?) for the Holocaust because of their national-family connections, but they were forbidden to experience other (positive?) national feelings and ascribe political relevance to them. Not for nothing did the political scientist Walter Reese-Schäfer

87. Habermas, “Der DM Nationalismus”; emphasis added. See the withering critique of Mark Lilla, who accuses Habermas of Rousseauian antiliberalism: “The Other Velvet Revolution: Continental Liberalism and Its Discontents,” Daedalus, no. 123 (1994): 129–57.

88. Jürgen Habermas, “Gelähmte Politik,” Der Spiegel, July 12, 1993, 54. Curiously, this quotation does not appear in the English translation of this essay: “Afterword (May 1993),” in The Past as Future, by Jürgen Habermas, ed. and trans. Max Pensky (London: Polity, 1994), 143–65.

89. Jürgen Habermas, “On the Public Use of History,” in New Conservatism, 233.

68 Dilemmas of Identity after the Holocaust point out that such a paradoxical anti-/postnationalism contained a religious dimension. Proscribing national feelings as a form of historical punishment made sense only to those for whom the nation mattered.90 To be sure, Habermas linked national and postnational consciousness by arguing that Auschwitz reminded Germans that they could not build their political identity on the former, but who or what was the “we” that was supposed to do the remembering in the long run? The community of penance was bound to disappear in the multicultural future he envisaged for Germany.

Pages:     | 1 |   ...   | 3 | 4 || 6 | 7 |   ...   | 11 |

Similar works:

«Teachers’ Notes written by Bronwyn Owen On the Jellicoe Road By Melina Marchetta Overview Taylor Markham is in year eleven at the Jellicoe School. She has just been made leader of the boarders by the secret society of students that have run the school, unofficially, for the last twenty years. Taylor is a reluctant leader – she is not particularly community-minded, preferring to escape at every opportunity to the unfinished house on the edge of the school where her house mistress, Hannah,...»

«Journal of Modern Physics, 2014, 5, 1537-1545 Published Online September 2014 in SciRes. http://www.scirp.org/journal/jmp http://dx.doi.org/10.4236/jmp.2014.515154 Worlds and Antiworlds Alexey V. Klimenko, Vladimir A. Klimenko Physics Department, Chelyabinsk State University, Chelyabinsk, Russia Email: alklimenko@gmail.com Received 22 June 2014; revised 15 July 2014; accepted 8 August 2014 Copyright © 2014 by authors and Scientific Research Publishing Inc. This work is licensed under the...»

«College of San Mateo Official Course Outline 1. COURSE ID: MATH 200 TITLE: Elementary Probability and Statistics Units: 4.0 units Hours/Semester: 64.0-72.0 Lecture hours; and 16.0-18.0 TBA hours Method of Grading: Letter Grade Only Prerequisite: MATH 120, or MATH 123 or MATH 190 or appropriate score on the College Placement Test.Recommended Preparation: eligibility for READ 400 or an equivalent level of reading proficiency and eligibility for ENGL 100 or 105. 2. COURSE DESIGNATION: Degree...»

«1st International Conference Science and Engineering in Arts, Heritage and Archaeology Book of Abstracts 14-15 July, 2015 University College London London, United Kingdom 1st International SEAHA Conference London, 14-15 July, 2015 Organising Committee Natalie Brown, SEAHA Doctoral Student Lucie Fusade, Committee Chair, SEAHA Doctoral Student Danny Garside, Associated SEAHA Doctoral Studen Yun Liu, SEAHA Doctoral Student Scott A. Orr, SEAHA Doctoral Student Bettina Sacher, SEAHA Doctoral Student...»

«See discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/228870335 Behavioral Foundations for Human-Centric Travel Decision-Aid Systems Abstract Article · July 2008 DOI: 10.1007/978-3-7091-6132-6_37 CITATIONS READS 3 authors, including: Ulrike Gretzel D.R. Fesenmaier University of Queensland Temple University 162 PUBLICATIONS 3,194 CITATIONS 122 PUBLICATIONS 3,739 CITATIONS SEE PROFILE SEE PROFILE Available from: Ulrike Gretzel...»

«The Stata Journal (2003) 3, Number 1, pp. 1–31 Instrumental variables and GMM: Estimation and testing Christopher F. Baum Mark E. Schaffer Boston College Heriot–Watt University Steven Stillman New Zealand Department of Labour Abstract. We discuss instrumental variables (IV) estimation in the broader context of the generalized method of moments (GMM), and describe an extended IV estimation routine that provides GMM estimates as well as additional diagnostic tests. Stand-alone test...»

«Climate Change Draft Scoping Plan a amework for change Appendices June 2008 Discussion Draft Pursuant to AB 32 e California Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006 Prepared by the California Air Resources Board for the State of California Arnold Schwarzenegger Governor Linda S. Adams Secretary, California Environmental Protection Agency Mary D. Nichols Chairman, Air Resources Board James N. Goldstene Executive O cer, Air Resources Board This Page Intentionally Blank Appendices Table of Contents...»

«USCA Case #10-3093 Document #1412404 Filed: 12/28/2012 Page 1 of 23 United States Court of Appeals FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA CIRCUIT Argued September 10, 2012 Decided December 28, 2012 No. 10-3093 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, APPELLEE v. ERNEST BERNARD MOORE, APPELLANT Appeal from the United States District Court for the District of Columbia (No. 1:09-cr-00250-1) Marie Park, appointed by the court, argued the cause and filed the briefs for appellant. David B. Goodhand, Assistant U.S. Attorney,...»

«TMSJ 18/1 (Fall 2007) 165-180 NEW COVENANT THEOLOGY AND THE OLD TESTAMENT COVENANTS W illiam D. Barrick Professor of Old Testament Though New Covenant Theology (NCT) has positive aspects such as an insistence on a biblically based theolog y, several asp ects of the system are no t so positive. For example, in pursuing a m iddle cou rse betwee n Disp ensation alism and Covenant Theolog y, its theologia ns rely on a strained view of Dispensationalism and adopt an interpretive methodology called...»

«Median and ulnar nerve injuries: prognosis and predictors for clinical outcome J. B. Jaquet ISBN 90-9018600-X © 2004 J. B. Jaquet Median and ulnar nerve injuries: prognosis and predictors for clinical outcome Jean-Bart Jaquet – Proefschrift Erasmus Universiteit Rotterdam. – Met samenvatting in het Nederlands Cover design and illustrations by G. F. Jaquet Printed by Optima Grafische Communicatie, Rotterdam, The Netherlands Median and ulnar nerve injuries: prognosis and predictors for...»

«Fondations De La Linguistique When you make to carry program to have confidentiality of construction and to fit accountable need, only justify sure about to remember to take to think steady resources. Particularly, when providing as credit, you is online for you run the Fondations de La Linguistique basis that Fondations de La Linguistique is much and real that my figure. Purchases like all becoming to clearly begin your kind and of you go to who they are is many you may purchase this online...»

«Нетворкинг для интровертов http://www.mann-ivanov-ferber.ru/books/paperbook/netvorking-dlya-introvertov/ Devora Zack Networking for People Who Hate Networking A Field Guide for Introverts, the Overwhelmed, and the Underconnected Berrett-Koehler Publishers http://www.mann-ivanov-ferber.ru/books/paperbook/netvorking-dlya-introvertov/ Девора Зак Нетворкинг для интровертов Перевод с английского Елены...»

<<  HOME   |    CONTACTS
2016 www.book.xlibx.info - Free e-library - Books, abstracts, thesis

Materials of this site are available for review, all rights belong to their respective owners.
If you do not agree with the fact that your material is placed on this site, please, email us, we will within 1-2 business days delete him.